fbpx

Accessibility Tools

  • You are here:  
  • Home /
  • Blogs /
  • Disability Royal Commission looks at the criminal justice system

Disability Royal Commission looks at the criminal justice system

Hits: 9296
bronze sculpture. Blindfolded woman holding scales.

The Disability Royal Commission is holding Public hearing 11: The experiences of people with cognitive disability in the criminal justice system. The hearing will be live-streamed from Tuesday 16 February – Thursday 25 February 2021.

Skip to: Live stream | Witness List | Transcripts | Media | Support | More info

Content Warning

Some of the stories and information below contain details about abuse, neglect and mistreatment of people with disability. There is support if you have any concerns because of this information.

How can I attend? 

Due to COVID-19, the hearing is not open to the public. It is available to watch or listen to online via the live stream. The hearing will be live-streamed from Tuesday 16 February – Thursday 25 February 2021.

What is it about? 

The public hearing will explore the experiences of violence, abuse, neglect and exploitation of people with disability, particularly people with cognitive impairment, in their interactions with the criminal justice system and the consequences which follow.

The public hearing is to investigate:

  • The factors contributing to people with a cognitive disability first coming into contact with the criminal justice system
  • How and why people with cognitive disability cycle in and out of the criminal justice system
  • How the criminal justice system can, and often does, criminalise disability
  • The overrepresentation of First Nations people with cognitive impairment within the criminal justice system, and any differences in their experience
  • The long term and indefinite incarceration of people with cognitive impairment under forensic custody orders 
  • The impact that appropriate diversion from the criminal justice system, and the provision of appropriate supports to people with disability, can have in reducing contact with the criminal justice system and in moving away from the criminalisation of disability

Live stream

Closed captions and Auslan translations provided as well as an audio-only stream

Witness List

Public hearing 11 - Witness list 

Exhibits

Official Transcripts

Opening Address

Opening Address Counsel Assisting - Public hearing 11, Brisbane [PDF]
Opening Address Counsel Assisting - Public hearing 11, Brisbane [DOCX]

Transcript Day 1 - Public hearing 11, Brisbane

Transcript Day 2 - Public hearing 11, Brisbane

Transcript Day 3 - Public hearing 11, Brisbane

Transcript Day 4 - Public hearing 11, Brisbane

Transcript Day 5 - Public hearing 11, Brisbane

Media Coverage

Sydney Morning Herald - 18 Feb

“The thing that stood out to me the most about that room is that Melanie had graffitied the room with her own blood,” said Ms Seares, a former chairwoman of the NSW Council for Intellectual Disability, and a solicitor from the Mental Health Advocacy Service.

“The smell of dried blood mixed with body odour and the sight of that graffiti is something that will be with me until the day I die.”

Read more: In seclusion, Melanie was so alone that she wrote on the walls in her own blood

SBS News - 16 Feb

An Indigenous woman with an intellectual disability was regularly kept in isolation for 23 hours a day and could have her freedom limited further depending on behaviour, a royal commission has been told. 

"Not one day in my life that I didn't want to get out and have a life and be happy again on the ward," Melanie said. "It was inhumane to keep someone locked up for that long in a seclusion area."

She lived in the isolated environment "almost constantly" for about seven years, until November 2020.

Read more: Cognitively-impaired Indigenous woman regularly isolated for 23 hours a day, disability inquiry hears

News.com.au - 16 Feb

Counsel assisting Janice Crawford said Melanie’s conditions were described as “Dickensian” by a forensic psychiatrist. Ms Crawford said a mental health review tribunal found Melanie’s rooms were:

“filthy and degrading … and clearly not conducive to any form of recovery. It is troubling indeed that a woman is held in such an environment in Australia in 2020, with little apparent hope of improvement and release,” she said.

Read more: Cognitively impaired woman isolated for 23 hours a day, inquiry told

ABC Radio: AM - 16 Feb

"The justice system holds significant barriers for people with disability and what we do is we tend to individualise those barriers. So we never question the system itself. We have various jurisdictions and so what happens is we individually support people to be able to access the justice system but not everybody has access to the same types of supports."

- Rosemary Kayes [academic and Human Rights lawyer]

Read more: How do people with disability navigate the justice system? 

Yahoo! News - 16 Feb

"Is the justice system being used as a de facto disability service, one that proceeds by punitive rather than therapeutic measures?"

- Kerri Mellifont [Senior Counsel Assisting]

Read more: Disability link to high prison numbers

Support Services

The Disability Royal Commission has set up support services for people with disability affected by or interacting with the Commission process. These supports include counselling, advocacy, financial and legal help. For more information and links read our resource on Royal Commission Support Services.

More Information

Go to Royal Commission into Violence, Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disability for our full coverage on the Disability Royal Commission or choose from some of the past hearings listed below. 

Past Hearings

Disability Royal Commission explores education and training of health care professionals in relation to people with cognitive disability 
Disability Royal Commission explores pathways and barriers to open employment for people with disability 
Disability Royal Commission - First Nations People with a Disability
Disability Royal Commission explores barriers to education 
Disability Royal Commission hearing on the use of psychotropic medication 
Disability Royal Commission Hearing on Emergency Planning 

Disability Royal Commission 

Phone: 1800 517 199
Web: disability.royalcommission.gov.au 
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. 

IDEAS does information so you can do life. 

Available Resources

a careworker helping a young girl in a seated position in an accessible home bathroom Disability Royal Commission public hearing 32 is revisiting disability service providers
hands cuffed in a barred cell Disability Royal Commission investigates conditions in detention in the criminal justice system
interior of public transport i.e. a bus Public hearing on violence against and abuse of people with disability in public places
hindu floral motif Public hearing on the experience of violence against, abuse, neglect and expoitation of people with disability from culturally and linguistically diverse communities
a pen and unsigned signature line on a document Public hearing on guardianship and supported decision-making for people with disabilities
hand drawn characters. one is a wheelchair user, one is a child, one is brown, one is white, some are wearing masks. words say inclusion Disability Royal Commission hearing focuses on a vision for an inclusive Australia
Indigenous dot painting in purple, blue, yellow, brown and green Public hearing on the operations of the NDIS for First Nations people with disability in remote communities
Two people. One is holding a drum, and one a guitar, they are making music and smiling. Music for the soul
Job application and résumé froms on a desk with reading glasses, folder, keyboard and coffee Disability Royal Commission examines the experience of people with disability engaging with Disability Employment Services
Young man with down syndrome wearing a hairnet, gloves and apron while peforming food handling tasks Disability Royal Commission examines the experience of people with disability working in Australian Disability Enteprises (ADE)
old fashioned brass balancing scales Disability Royal Commission looks at preventing and responding to violence, abuse, neglect and exploitation in disability services
girl with down syndrome looking down sadly Royal Commission looking at preventing and responding to violence, abuse, neglect and exploitation in disability services
In the background is a persons hand on a braille keyboard next to a keyboard. On an orange background are the words Royal Commission - Measures taken by employers and regulators to respond to the systemic barriers to open employment for people with disability
universal symbol for man and universal symbol for disability (a person in a wheelchair) on a balancing beam Royal Commission looks at the human rights of people with disability and making the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities a reality in Australian law, policies and practice
Files on a background with the words Royal Commission publishes Disability in Australia and Agents of Our Own Destiny reports
A girl with glasses and dark hair with intellectual disability is using a laptop computer Council for Intellectual Disability Position Statement on Technology
A wooden tray with multicoloured rice within. A childs hand is playing in the tray. There are toys and tools around the tray. A recipe for sensory play
woman in a wheelchair with purple flowing hair Royal Commission investigates experience of women and girls with disability
vaccine bottle and syringe with covid spore Draft Report finds COVID-19 vaccine strategy and roll-out for people with disability seriously deficient
young Indigenous boy looking sad Royal Commission looks at First Nations children with disability in out-of-home care
Rainbow coloured scales of justice Disability Royal Commission investigates People with cognitive disability and the Criminal justice system and NDIS
A boy with cerebral palsy smiles at a woman standing alongside him. Skills for life
Detail image of broken wicker or cane Royal Commission looks at the Ann-Marie Smith case and continues investigating abuse in disability support services
a gloved ahnd gholding a bottle labelled covid-19 vaccine and a syringe. Public hearing to examine the COVID-19 vaccine roll-out for people with disability
Your Story Disability Support Call 1800 77 1800 Your Story Disability Legal Support
Woman in wheelchair with back turned. A laptop with another woman on screen holding a book. Disability Royal Commission looks at preventing and responding to violence, abuse, neglect and exploitation in disability services
A small hand holds up an orange coloured plastic easter egg. In the background are blurred easter eggs on green. Disability Inclusive Easter
sad woman in cage. IDEAS logo. IDEAS does information so you can do life. Disability Royal Commission seeks submissions with latest issues papers
Disability Royal Commission - Hearing Update Disability Royal Commission explores education and training of health care professionals in relation to people with congitive disability
Royal Commission - pathways and barriers to open employment. Disability Royal Commission explores pathways and barriers to open employment for people with disability
aerial view of driveway and burnt house and bush Are you Bushfire Ready?
‘Respectful Listening’ depicts the story of The Disability Royal Commission, translated into a traditional style of art and symbols used by many of Australia’s First peoples to share information and stories for thousands of years. This story is made up of seven people who are Elders and or respected members of their own communities. These seven people, the Commissioners, come from different community groups including Australia’s First People, people living with disability and the LGBTIQ+ community. Disability Royal Commission - First Nations People with a Disability
children, teacher and assistance dog sitting on the floor in a library reading a book as a group Disability Royal Commission explores barriers to education
Disability Royal Commission Hearing Upgrade - The use of psychotropic medication, behaviour support and behaviours of concern - man with Down Syndrome looking reflective in black and white Disability Royal Commission hearing on the use of psychotropic medication
Bold words say hearing update - disability royal commission emergency planning and response in the background is a montage of news paper articles in black and white on disability Disability Royal Commission Hearing on Emergency Planning
sad woman with hands over her eyes Disability service Integrity Care banned from providing NDIS services
Blonde woman laughing with a man, who is seated in a wheechair Righting the wrongs: building safer lives for people with disabillity
Indigenous dot painting called Respectful Listening by Wiradjuri Elder Paul Calcott First Nations people with disability matter
woman with purple hair bound by an orange rope. Royal Commission seeks comment for Issue Papers
Image of young girl with Down Syndrome looking sad Shocking cases of disability abuse and neglect come to light
Reporting Abuse - Woman sitting on a couch with her hand up to indicate stop. She has Down Syndrome.ffy dog tha is being held by a woman Reporting abuse of people with a disability
medical drip with patient in background Royal Commission looks into health for people with intellectual disability
hands holding a blue house made of paper Second hearing of Royal Commission investigates violence and abuse in group homes
Preteen school boy with down syndrome working a desk in a classroom with a pencil in hand First hearing of Royal Commission focuses on education
Image of rainbow watercolour silhouettes. Two people. One speaking. Royal Commission support services
Image of Brisbane Convention and Exhibition Centre exterior First public sitting of Disability Royal Commission
Image of businessman's hand writing on paper Royal Commission seeks submissions
Image of a microphone at a lectern in a formal inquiry chamber Pressure mounts for Disability Royal Commissioners to stand down
small boy with hearing aid Why schools desperately need a royal commission into the abuse of disabled people
White text reads Growing Up Disabled in Australia
Sexuality - NSW Council for Intellectual Disability Sexuality - NSW Council for Intellectual Disability